Compact Freezers · head to head

Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON vs Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W

The Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON and the Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W are both compact freezers in the same size and price class. Below is a side-by-side of their real capacity, dimensions, energy use, and current prices so you can pick the one that fits your space and budget — no invented ratings, just the specs and live pricing.

Our pick

Our pick: the Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON

Frigidaire gives you more space for your money — $57 vs $62 per cu ft.

The Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W does not lead on any measured spec here.

FrigidaireFrigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON 4.5 cu ft Compact Freezer White

$256at Amazon

View best pricePrice as of 07/16/2026

View price at Amazon$256

Antarctic StarAntarctic Star 58128RRE1-W 4.5 cu ft Fridge/Freezer White

$280at Amazon

View best pricePrice as of 07/16/2026

View price at Amazon$280

At a glance

Lower priceFrigidaire — Frigidaire is $24 cheaper at last check.

More capacityTie — Both hold about 4.5 cu ft.

Better value per cu ftFrigidaire — Frigidaire gives you more space for your money — $57 vs $62 per cu ft.

Specifications, side by side

Specification comparison: Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON versus Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W.
Spec	Frigidaire	Antarctic Star
Type	Compact Freezers	Compact Freezers
Model	EFR489AMZCOTTON	58128RRE1-W
Capacity	4.5 cu ft	4.5 cu ft
Dimensions	—	20.3" W × 31.7" H × 22.1" D
Energy use	—	—
Color	White	White
Price	$256at Amazon View best pricePrice as of 07/16/2026	$280at Amazon View best pricePrice as of 07/16/2026

Prices re-checked on a schedule; tap a price for the live number at the retailer.

Frequently asked

Which should you buy, the Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON or the Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W?

Our pick: the Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON. Frigidaire gives you more space for your money — $57 vs $62 per cu ft. The Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W does not lead on any measured spec here.

Is the Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON or the Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W cheaper?

Frigidaire is $24 cheaper at last check.

Which holds more, the Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON or the Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W?

Both hold about 4.5 cu ft.

Which gives more freezer space per dollar, the Frigidaire EFR489AMZCOTTON or the Antarctic Star 58128RRE1-W?